Posnanski Flunks Krzyzewski

The Kansas City Star’s Joe Posnanski is perhaps the best-regarded sports columnist (and blogger!) in the country, which is why his latest column from Beijing is relevant–that, and it’s the sharpest rebuke of Team USA head coach Mike Krzyzewski yet. Posnanski’s column, “Give Coach K an F for diplomacy,” criticizes Krzyzewski for belittling a foreign reporter who asked the Duke head coach why Team USA felt the need to dunk even in garbage time of its 101-70 win over China Sunday.

“There was no showing off,” Krzyzewski said before glaring at the reporter. “You dunk when you have to dunk. They have 7-footers. If you don’t take it hard, Yao would block it. He did block one…. I don’t know your definition of showing off, to me that’s hard basketball. I thought we played very hard. I thought we took it to the basket hard. Don’t confuse hard with showing off.”

Posnanski offers four ways, of many, that Krzyzewski could have maintained the humble approach Team USA has favored:

Example 1: He could have said that the United States has great athletes, and they love to perform. This is absolutely true. Dunking is an act of joy in American basketball, and frankly if I could dunk like Dwyane Wade, I would probably never leave the playground.

Example 2: He could have said the players were obviously motivated and pumped up by the amazing crowd. This is absolutely true, too. Krzyzewski could have said the arena was electric and alive, and the players certainly meant no disrespect when they dunked, they were simply responding to the spirit and passion of the people in the stands. This has the added advantage of praising the Chinese fans, which certainly would not hurt the team’s standing.

Example 3: He could have said, “Personally, I wish our players would show off by making a few three-point shots.” Or, to play off the theme, he could have said that his players were dunking so ferociously because they could not hit anything from outside 5 feet. The U.S. missed 11 of 12 three-point shots in the first half, and this was the one downer of the game. This team, like pretty much every American team of the last few years, does not have great outside shooting – what happened to our outside shooters anyway? Did someone tear down the driveway goals in Indiana, Kentucky and Carolina? Did they stop playing HORSE on playgrounds in the city? Doesn’t anyone have Reggie Miller’s phone number?

Example 4: He could have said that fans want to see those dunks. And it’s true. The NBA is enormously popular in China – the word is that there are several jerseys in China (beginning with Kobe Bryant) that now outsell Yao Ming jerseys. The fans finally have a chance to see some of their heroes play live and in person. You think they want to see underhand-layups? Uh, no. They want to see LeBron James throw down his dunks.

Of course, glares from Krzyzewski after tough questions (and particularly tough columns) have become relatively commonplace for Chronicle reporters, so we can sympathize with the journalist in question. But what do you think: Was Coach K wrong for snapping at this reporter? Should he have simply deflected the question? Or was he in his rights?

–by Ben Cohen


Filed under Media, Men's Basketball, Olympics

4 responses to “Posnanski Flunks Krzyzewski

  1. I think Coach K’s response was less than stellar, but nothing to freak out about. Reporters at the Olympics this time around are very critical of everything from a 15-minute delay to other countries’ celebrations. And with a high-profile team and sport in general in the mix, reporters’ sensationalist fingers attack their keyboards quicker than Duke leaves the big dance.

    I want to hear your opinion, Ben. What do you think?

  2. Jason

    I totally disagree with you. First of all, Coach K is responding to a question posed to him on the spot. You’ve had ample time to think about what he should have said so you could write it in a blog. Give Coach K a day to think over a question and he’ll give you the best answer you’ve ever heard. Why do you think Fortune 500 companies pay him tens of thousands to speak to their employees. Also, if you’ve followed Coach K throughout the years (as I’m sure you have), you’d understand that he only knows how to play and coach one way…INTENSE!! So, no matter what the score or situation, you never take a possession off.

  3. Mike

    Sounds like another typical overreaction to K’s style. It is fashionable now to hate K and Duke so some writers look for any reason to find fault with what he does or says. As far as the Olympics has been concerned K is d****ed if he does d***ed if doesn’t. He was criticised for who he picked for the team; He is now being criticised for them winning and how they win. The best of us probably would loose it a little. If they weren’t dunking I’m sure this writer would accuse K of forcing this team of fabulous athletes to play his “concervative Duke-style of basketball.” Or that the team was playing soft. I think the point he is trying to make is that USA will play hard run, take it to the basket and if you want to stop us you’re going to have to try.

  4. alum

    This is such a non-issue, it’s ridiculous. If Posnanski is such a good journalist, then he should be able to find something more worthwhile to devote a whole column to.

    Coach K is already going to (unfairly) take the brunt of the criticism if we don’t win the Gold. Now people like Posnanski won’t even let him do that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s